Got a tip for Noah?
SEND IT!
(Guaranteed Confidential)
Subscribe

Subscribe via RSS

Archives by Date
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006

See all Archives
Archives by Category
'Canes
Ammo and Munitions
Armor
Axe in Iraq (and Elsewhere)
Bizarro
Blimps
Blog Bidness
Bomb Squad
Cammo Green
Chem-Bio
Cloak and Dagger
Comms
Cops and Robbers
Data Diving
Dissent Tech
Drones
Eat My Dust
Eye on China
FCS Watch
FOS Files
Gadgets and Gear
Ground Vehicles
Guns
Homeland Security
Info War
Iraq Diary
Lasers and Ray Guns
Less-lethal
Logistics
Los Alamos and Labs
Medic!
Mercs
Missiles
Money Money Money
Net-Centric
Nukes
Planes, Copters, Blimps
Politricks
Rapid Fire
Raptor Watch
Red Team
Retro-Futuro
Roll Your Own
Sabra Tech
Ships and Subs
Space
Strategery
Terror Tech
The Deadlies
Those Nutty Norks
Training and Sims
War Update
You can run...

See all Archives
Related Links
News and Intel
Military.com News
Aviation Week
Natl Defense Mag
Strategy Page
Global Security Newswire
Soldiers for the Truth
Security News
Defense Review
Fed Comp Week

Security Sources
GlobalSecurity.Org
Fed Am Sci
CSIS
Ctr for Defense Info
Defense & Natl Interest
Instit for Sci & Intl Secy
Secrecy News
POGO
Cryptome
The Memory Hole
Natl Security Archive

Geeks and Mad Scientists
Slashdot
Wired News
Security Focus
The Register
Gizmodo
Geek Press
Robots.Net
Cosmic Log
Space Daily
New Scientist
TechCentralStation
Engadget
Space.Com
Technology Review
Gyre
Near Near Future
Fed Dev Blog

Bloggers and Buddies
Phil Carter
Global Guerillas
Jeffrey Lewis
Milblogging
OPFOR
Laura Rozen
Larisa Alexandrovna
Juan Cole
Ryan Singel
Josh Marshall
Cursor
Boing Boing
InstaPundit
Winds of Change
Tapped
TalkLeft
Brad DeLong
Mountain Runner
Gene Healy
Clive Thompson
Greg Djerejian
Jeff Quinton
Workbench
Electrolite
Jim Henley
War in Context
Kathryn Cramer
Wash Park Prophet
Blogs of War
Tom Shachtman

Official Dispatches
DARPA
AF Research Lab
Marine War Lab
Soldier Systems Ctr
Naval Research
Army Research Lab
UK Def Sci Lab
NASA News
DoJ Cybercrime

Military Network
Military Benefits
Veteran Employment
GI Bill Express
Personnel Locator
Free ASVAB
The Few
Fred's Place
Army Insider
Navy Insider
Air Force Insider
Marine Corps Insider
Coast Guard Insider



Edited by Noah Shachtman | Contact

The Best Weapon

On Feb. 2, M-1 driver Cpl. Walter Howard, 35, was maneuvering his tank against insurgents near the town of Balad when an IED exploded, killing him instantly. At his memorial service today, officers and soldiers wept and held each other. A general, colonels and sergeants major clapped shoulders and doled out hugs. An entire battalion and their brigade leadership poured out their hearts. It was hard to watch.

Balad_memorial.jpgHoward, a former Seabee with a wife and a daughter, is the first fatality suffered by Alpha Company, 1-8 Infantry, which since December has occupied a crappy little FOB called McKenzie, where MREs pass for food, the mud is ankle-deep and the mood is plain glum. Theirs is the bad side of Balad; almost every day they take fire from disaffected Sunnis in the city's suburbs. IEDs are a constant threat. And while everyone hopes that Howard will be the only KIA here, most know better.

Still, every day Alpha Company rides out in their Humvees, M-2 Bradleys and tanks. Every day they walk the area's filthy streets, knocking on doors or kicking them down, following leads, rounding up bad guys and doing what they can to win the hearts of these poor, untrusting people. Every day they face death side by side, motivated in part by patriotism, duty, pay, their desire to help Iraqis or a lack of anything better to do, but mostly by their love for each other and their refusal to let each other down.

Never mind radio jammers, armored vehicles and drones. Never mind multi-billion-dollar programs like FBCB2 and Blue Force Tracker. The real secret weapon of this nasty little war is the young grunt on the ground, the guy who faces Iraq's million little problems with a million little solutions of his own, every day for a year at a time, and who -- while folks back home decry the monetary cost of this war -- bears the true cost, in his blood.

God bless the Army, Navy and Marine Corps.

-- David Axe

Latest Comments

This man that died,was not driving a bradley. He was driving an M1A2 Abrams tank. The explosive device was very powerful but did not penetrate the thick hull of the Tank. But,the concussion was so powerful that it threw him around inside the tank,killing him instantly. I know this because my son is at FOB Mckenzie and is part of this man's unit and had become a close friend. He(my son) used to tell me things that they talked about. I spent 10 yrs in the navy and worked 2 yrs as a seabee so my son and him would talk about my experiences all the time. These men are heros. My son,when he calls, never tells me anything about the daily grind he deals with at FOB Mckenzie. He knows his job.He knows he is a military fighting man and accepts the conditions and situations he is given. BTW he could be on one of those patrols as I write this.

Posted by: wrknman43 at February 18, 2006 10:24 PM


I am no edxpert psychologist but you sort of throw hearts and minds out the window when you kill 100,000 Iraqi Military that have families and friends.

And you sort of cant really expect any respect for your cause (no matter how just) when you are shooting munitions that are either scaring, scarring, or killing civilians.

I know if some States revolted against .gov to restore our civil rights and were killing innocents like family and friends and dropping bombs on my neighborhood, I would not like them very much and would probably plot their deaths, even though I supported their cause.

Posted by: jtw at February 13, 2006 5:22 PM


This war is not about oil anymore. And supposedly it never was.
However, one thing most people in the administration have not understood: THIS WAR IS ABOUT HEARTS AND MIDS!
American hearts and minds are with our troops. And our troops have to catch Iraqy hearts and minds!
Democracy is under way but it will take more time. Sad to say - more blood is going to be shed on both sides.
But technology is NOT the answer.

Funny but true: German troops are patroling Afghanistan (their equipment is mostly inadequat and they have less then 5% of the money to spend per soldier compared to the US) but they are doing well with the natives.

Posted by: Thinker at February 13, 2006 8:34 AM


"The real secret weapon of this nasty little war is the young grunt on the ground"

I agree. I wish they got more attention. I used to work for a DoD department with a big budget and lots of technology. The story they told about what they were doing was great but they never delivered. Everything was rubber stamped TS. Not because it was but because they didn't want any other command promising to do what they promised to do and compete for their budget.

It was disgusting to watch the waste. Multiple fiber optic networks installed and abandoned. Constant expensive computer systems upgrades to fix their own mistakes. A commander who spent more time polishing up his bs powerpoint slides so he give the dog and pony one more time to expand the budget, and picking out carpet swatches for the new building. Analysts who during the opening days of OIF sat around arguing about whether or not the command logo was included because they knew that when it was all over we would be looking to see who contributed or not and adjust budgets accordingly.

The "analysts" who are supposed to be experts. Many of them 20 year old new hires with only a BS/BA. Most of the older analysts left for various reasons and replaced by young graduats, many of whome were briefing commanders, producing reports and even doing BDA within a matter of months and presenting themselves as subject matter experts.

"while folks back home decry the monetary cost of this war"

Please know that while I decry the cost of the war it has nothing to do with supporting the troops. If you guys need it I think you sould get it. The cost of your needs are probably a fraction of the waste state side. I know much of that money is not being spent on you because I have seen much of that money being spent on sexy, high tech projects who only sell promises and deliver bills.

Posted by: Jason at February 12, 2006 10:13 AM


Maybe if we did'nt overspend by billiosn on these FBCB2 and Blue Force Trackers and spend 3 billion on mini paper machete' amatuer model airplanes we would of had technology that could of detected the buried explosive that killed this soldier in his bradley.

Posted by: jtw at February 11, 2006 8:20 PM


» View All 17 Comments

» Post a Comment