Got a tip for Noah?
SEND IT!
(Guaranteed Confidential)
Subscribe

Subscribe via RSS

Archives by Date
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006

See all Archives
Archives by Category
'Canes
Ammo and Munitions
Armor
Axe in Iraq (and Elsewhere)
Bizarro
Blimps
Blog Bidness
Bomb Squad
Cammo Green
Chem-Bio
Cloak and Dagger
Comms
Cops and Robbers
Data Diving
Dissent Tech
Drones
Eat My Dust
Eye on China
FCS Watch
FOS Files
Gadgets and Gear
Ground Vehicles
Guns
Homeland Security
Info War
Iraq Diary
Lasers and Ray Guns
Less-lethal
Logistics
Los Alamos and Labs
Medic!
Mercs
Missiles
Money Money Money
Net-Centric
Nukes
Planes, Copters, Blimps
Politricks
Rapid Fire
Raptor Watch
Red Team
Retro-Futuro
Roll Your Own
Sabra Tech
Ships and Subs
Space
Strategery
Terror Tech
The Deadlies
Those Nutty Norks
Training and Sims
War Update
You can run...

See all Archives
Related Links
News and Intel
Military.com News
Aviation Week
Natl Defense Mag
Strategy Page
Global Security Newswire
Soldiers for the Truth
Security News
Defense Review
Fed Comp Week

Security Sources
GlobalSecurity.Org
Fed Am Sci
CSIS
Ctr for Defense Info
Defense & Natl Interest
Instit for Sci & Intl Secy
Secrecy News
POGO
Cryptome
The Memory Hole
Natl Security Archive

Geeks and Mad Scientists
Slashdot
Wired News
Security Focus
The Register
Gizmodo
Geek Press
Robots.Net
Cosmic Log
Space Daily
New Scientist
TechCentralStation
Engadget
Space.Com
Technology Review
Gyre
Near Near Future
Fed Dev Blog

Bloggers and Buddies
Phil Carter
Global Guerillas
Jeffrey Lewis
Milblogging
OPFOR
Laura Rozen
Larisa Alexandrovna
Juan Cole
Ryan Singel
Josh Marshall
Cursor
Boing Boing
InstaPundit
Winds of Change
Tapped
TalkLeft
Brad DeLong
Mountain Runner
Gene Healy
Clive Thompson
Greg Djerejian
Jeff Quinton
Workbench
Electrolite
Jim Henley
War in Context
Kathryn Cramer
Wash Park Prophet
Blogs of War
Tom Shachtman

Official Dispatches
DARPA
AF Research Lab
Marine War Lab
Soldier Systems Ctr
Naval Research
Army Research Lab
UK Def Sci Lab
NASA News
DoJ Cybercrime

Military Network
Military Benefits
Veteran Employment
GI Bill Express
Personnel Locator
Free ASVAB
The Few
Fred's Place
Army Insider
Navy Insider
Air Force Insider
Marine Corps Insider
Coast Guard Insider



Edited by Noah Shachtman | Contact

PM's "Lessons of Katrina"

You won't like, or agree with, every conclusion -- especially not if you work for the mayor of New Orleans. But Popular Mechanics' ridiculously comprehensive cover package on the "Lessons of Katrina" is really worth a read.

PMX0306leveefailpresc-lg.jpgEspecially nice is how Pop Mech leverages its DIY home-builder know-how to offer up fixes for future hurricane-fighting. Here's an example:

In 1965, the same year Hurricane Betsy swamped large sections of New Orleans (including the Lower Ninth Ward), the Army Corps of Engineers presented Congress with an audacious blueprint for protecting the city from a fast-moving Category 3 storm. The $85 million Barrier Plan proposed sealing off Lake Pontchartrain from the gulf with massive, retractable flood barriers. The goal: Stop storm surges 25 miles east of the levees that encircle New Orleans. After Betsy, the plan was expanded to include gates on two of the four drainage canals that slice into the city from Pontchartrain (two of which breached their floodwalls after Katrina). But, environmental groups objected to the impact that the Pontchartrain floodgates might have on wildlife and wetlands. The Sewer and Water Board of New Orleans vetoed gates on the canals. So the Corps instead built higher levees and floodwalls.

Now, 40 years later, the Corps is again studying how to design gates for Pontchartrain and the New Orleans canals that will have minimal impact on the environment and navigation, but will still be able to block Katrina-strength storm surges. The report's due date: January 2008. Meanwhile, engineers are also studying how to strengthen the existing levees. One idea is to replace fragile I-wall barriers with more robust T-walls, which use three rows of foundation pilings that can withstand pressure generated by hurricane-force floodwaters. A wide concrete slab, or "skirt," on the protected side deflects overflowing water that could otherwise wash away supporting soil. T-walls held throughout Katrina without a leak.

Next month's cover story might not be half-bad, either. I hear they got some defense technology dork to look at the Pentagon's big weapons programs, and try to figure out who things are meant to fight.

Latest Comments

If you think this would be enough, then your creativeness is not enough. There are still features that may be added on to disaster preparedness system. Due to sensitivity of the subject, I'll zip my mouth to go further on the subject.

Posted by: pedestrian at March 7, 2006 10:42 AM


Nice pseudo-covert shameless plug for next month. Looking forward to it.

Posted by: JK at March 6, 2006 11:19 AM


Charles: sadly, a house built on a concrete foundation, no matter how high, will eventually sink into the mud. There is no bedrock to build on down there because of tens of thousands of years of sediment buildup. Venice is sinking, too.

Does anyone know how the Aztecs managed to build their city in the middle of a lake? Were they building on floating "islands?"

You're quite right that maintaining a city there is expensive and can only be done with constant maintainance of the levees. Having a port there would seem to be worth it, but if that is the case, the port should generate enough revenue to maintain the system. Of course, you can also argue that California cities ought to be able to pay for their own water supply without Federal funding if it's really worth it to live there. Good luck with that.

Posted by: James at March 5, 2006 10:29 PM


"I remember a story i heard on talk radio a month back,where,a building contractor with an engenius
device that could take cast off building materials,lumber,concrete,sheet rock,ect,and chum it up into usable building materials"

Lumber turns rotten (especially after a hurricane, innundation in salt water etc), nails turn rusty, concrete that is "chummed" will be brittle...any other reasons why we try not to recycle old construction material? More circumstancial evidence: or maybe because everyone knows that CON ARTISTS prey on SURVIVORS. (I've decided to borrow capitalizing text sections from commentators like Ann Coulter). No offense, but the way you state the "concept" reminds me of some "As Seen on TV" gimmick. Give me a link, if one exists.

It's always a reality that con artists prey on the desperate, and nobody's more desperate than if your entire region has been blasted back to the Iron Age by a giant hurricane. Maybe you listen to those mails with proposals to transfer money from foreign countries?

Now, back to New Orleans.

The city is built on a crappy place. In the Netherlands they spend waaay more on /their/ levee systems. They have giant moving gates and box in their countryside with levees (sort of like compartmentalization of a ship), spending boatloads of money on the system to keep their country from going under. If you're not willing to spend that kind of dough, maybe you shouldn't be living there.

Or you could buy a house with a 12 foot high base of concrete and/or stilts.

Posted by: Charles at March 5, 2006 2:35 PM


We are $8 trillion in the hole and we really think Congress can help us? Still? The petro-euro has a good chance too be teaching us differently, and very soon. It shall be forced upon us, when the greenback breaks, to stop going to Congress for solving local problems and grow the manual community once more -- the collapse of Federalism.

I know building a levy without Congress' help will require some inventive ideas, such as katsesama mentioned, but our inherent laziness, we call quality of life, proves it will take more iterations, more "Lessons of Katrina" moments, before we grow up and face the pain it takes to rebuild our nation.

So much poisonous seepage to clean up, unstoppable mass extinction of many untold species, and toil humans have cause and produced in the last 100 years -- us playing god, we have failed, especially with the US river system. Lets just hope we haven't push too much irreversible pain onto the world in the process and survive another 100 years.

Posted by: mycall at March 5, 2006 1:57 AM


» View All 8 Comments

» Post a Comment