Got a tip for Noah?
SEND IT!
(Guaranteed Confidential)
Subscribe

Subscribe via RSS

Archives by Date
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006

See all Archives
Archives by Category
'Canes
Ammo and Munitions
Armor
Axe in Iraq (and Elsewhere)
Bizarro
Blimps
Blog Bidness
Bomb Squad
Cammo Green
Chem-Bio
Cloak and Dagger
Comms
Cops and Robbers
Data Diving
Dissent Tech
Drones
Eat My Dust
Eye on China
FCS Watch
FOS Files
Gadgets and Gear
Ground Vehicles
Guns
Homeland Security
Info War
Iraq Diary
Lasers and Ray Guns
Less-lethal
Logistics
Los Alamos and Labs
Medic!
Mercs
Missiles
Money Money Money
Net-Centric
Nukes
Planes, Copters, Blimps
Politricks
Rapid Fire
Raptor Watch
Red Team
Retro-Futuro
Roll Your Own
Sabra Tech
Ships and Subs
Space
Strategery
Terror Tech
The Deadlies
Those Nutty Norks
Training and Sims
War Update
You can run...

See all Archives
Related Links
News and Intel
Military.com News
Aviation Week
Natl Defense Mag
Strategy Page
Global Security Newswire
Soldiers for the Truth
Security News
Defense Review
Fed Comp Week

Security Sources
GlobalSecurity.Org
Fed Am Sci
CSIS
Ctr for Defense Info
Defense & Natl Interest
Instit for Sci & Intl Secy
Secrecy News
POGO
Cryptome
The Memory Hole
Natl Security Archive

Geeks and Mad Scientists
Slashdot
Wired News
Security Focus
The Register
Gizmodo
Geek Press
Robots.Net
Cosmic Log
Space Daily
New Scientist
TechCentralStation
Engadget
Space.Com
Technology Review
Gyre
Near Near Future
Fed Dev Blog

Bloggers and Buddies
Phil Carter
Global Guerillas
Jeffrey Lewis
Milblogging
OPFOR
Laura Rozen
Larisa Alexandrovna
Juan Cole
Ryan Singel
Josh Marshall
Cursor
Boing Boing
InstaPundit
Winds of Change
Tapped
TalkLeft
Brad DeLong
Mountain Runner
Gene Healy
Clive Thompson
Greg Djerejian
Jeff Quinton
Workbench
Electrolite
Jim Henley
War in Context
Kathryn Cramer
Wash Park Prophet
Blogs of War
Tom Shachtman

Official Dispatches
DARPA
AF Research Lab
Marine War Lab
Soldier Systems Ctr
Naval Research
Army Research Lab
UK Def Sci Lab
NASA News
DoJ Cybercrime

Military Network
Military Benefits
Veteran Employment
GI Bill Express
Personnel Locator
Free ASVAB
The Few
Fred's Place
Army Insider
Navy Insider
Air Force Insider
Marine Corps Insider
Coast Guard Insider



Edited by Noah Shachtman | Contact

Arabs to Hezbollah: Up Yours

Fascinating. "Arab governments... have not come to Hezbollah’s defense — not even Syria and Iran," the Times is reporting. (Although Iran did threaten to retaliate if Israel attacked Syria.)

1701iranb.jpgIsrael was also pleased by a statement from the Saudi government on Thursday that blamed Hezbollah for adventurism and called on it to end the crisis.

"A distinction must be made between legitimate resistance and uncalculated adventures taken by elements inside Lebanon and those behind them without recourse to the legal authorities or consulting and coordinating with Arab nations," said a statement published on the official [Saudi] news agency SPA. "These elements should bear the responsibility for their irresponsible actions and they alone should end the crisis they have created."

FP Passport has more. Meanwhile, my G'town homey Greg Djerjian, who's dad served as ambassador to both Israel and Syria, advises the Israelis (and the U.S.) not to get too cocky.

Stratfor
explains why the sabras probably won't listen:

Israel lives with three realities: geographic, demographic and cultural. Geographically, it is at a permanent disadvantage, lacking strategic depth. It does enjoy the advantage of interior lines -- the ability to move forces rapidly from one front to another. Demographically, it is on the whole outnumbered, although it can achieve local superiority in numbers by choosing the time and place of war. Its greatest advantage is cultural. It has a far greater mastery of the technology and culture of war than its neighbors.

Two of the realities cannot be changed. Nothing can be done about geography or demography. Culture can be changed. It is not inherently the case that Israel will have a technological or operational advantage over its neighbors. The great inherent fear of Israel is that the Arabs will equal or surpass Israeli prowess culturally and therefore militarily. If that were to happen, then all three realities would turn against Israel and Israel might well be at risk.

That is why the capture of Israeli troops, first one in the south, then two in the north, has galvanized Israel. The kidnappings represent a level of Arab tactical prowess that previously was the Israeli domain. They also represent a level of tactical slackness on the Israeli side that was previously the Arab domain. These events hardly represent a fundamental shift in the balance of power. Nevertheless, for a country that depends on its cultural superiority, any tremor in this variable reverberates dramatically. Hamas and Hezbollah have struck the core Israeli nerve. Israel cannot ignore it...

It is difficult to overestimate the impact of the soldier kidnappings on the Israeli psyche... Having a soldier kidnapped by Arabs hits every family in the country. ...

The more fundamental issue is this: Israel withdrew from Lebanon in order to escape low-intensity conflict. If Hezbollah is now going to impose low-intensity conflict on Israel's border, the rationale for withdrawal disappears. It is better for Israel to fight deep in Lebanon than inside Israel. If the rockets are going to fall in Israel proper, then moving into a forward posture has no cost to Israel.

One last thing -- has anyone seen confirmation of this Counterterrorism Blog tidbit? "According to Israeli Channel 10, Hezbollah was able to hack into the Israeli Army's computer systems prior to the attack."

Latest Comments

CIVILLIANS DIED BECAUSE HEZ WERE USUING THEM AS SHEILDS

Posted by: TIM at August 24, 2006 5:09 PM


babykillers=US ARMY.... babykillers=IDF... You will lose in the end...

Posted by: The Turks at August 6, 2006 8:12 AM


I SUPPORT ISRAEL THEY HAVE THE ONLY TRUE GOD ON THERE SIDE

Posted by: SAMSON at July 26, 2006 4:47 PM


I think it is very amusing that America and Israel think it is Ok to bomb and invade other countries causing huge casualties but when these countries retaliate they are "terrorists"...would you really just sit by and watch your country invaded and bombed by these countries...no you would fight and that is what is happening...
As for Lebanon i would also like to add that Israel isn’t targeting terrorist cells they are targeting airports, hotels and main roads...Do you think its a coincidence that when Lebanon finally becomes a holiday haven for the middle east again and has rebuilt its self after 15 years of peace and is becoming increasingly wealthy that they chose now to bomb them? i think not...Lebanon has been trying for may years to stop terrorist groups in there country but have not been successful...so how is it the countries fault that these two men were kidnapped? Israel didn’t even give the county warning that they were going to war…that just shows how cowardly they really are… America acts like they don’t have terrorist groups...Perhaps they should look at the people in there own back yard before judging others...How many innocent men, women and children have died as a result of American and Israeli heavy handedness…who are the real terrorists here?

Posted by: Belinda at July 16, 2006 9:41 PM


Ghost,

It seems you are misinformed of the targets that Israel has been bombing over the last few days, and in fact lebanon in general. Mud Huts are not viable militaty trgest, nor what in fact are beinf bombed. Lebanon has not had a war for 15 years, and over te last few years a large amount of money has been invested in resorts, casinos, hotels and tourisim (the airpost as mentioned by Joseph.) The areas that are being targeted are not those which are known to house Hezbollah insurgents, but include weathly christain area's. It seems the criteria in which targets are being selected is also based on the wealth that these areas generatoe for lebanon, weath that is not being used to fund Hezbollah, but to develop a country that is trying to rebuild in one of the most war torn regions on the planet.

As far as those that think that civilan targets are "right and just" , this seems only to apply when its not occuring in your own cities.

Posted by: James Keppel at July 16, 2006 9:11 PM


» View All 11 Comments

» Post a Comment